Scheel Letters: Recent Crossings

Courtesy of

ARK - Arizona Rivulin Keepers


The Scheel Letters, No. 18

Recent Crossings

In between the "production" of eggs for you I have to go on in crossing the different species. This is done by the way that I isolate some females in one tank and some males in another tank and each Sunday I place one male and one female together in a 2-4 liters glass only with little perlon and hope the crossing to come. Sometimes I am successful, sometimes not. One Sunday gave 6 different combinations, other Sundays gave not a single egg. Some females and some males are excellent for crossings, some are not willing to spawn with any strange partner.

Aphyosemion australe male / Epiplatys chaperi female: this cross was difficult to establish as the female did not want to spawn with this male.

Aphyosemion australe male / Aphyosemion cognatum female: Aphyosemion australe male / Aphyosemion schoutedeni female: Aphyosemion cognatum male / Aphyosemion schoutedeni female: Aphyosemion labarrei male / Aphyosemion schoutedeni female: Aphyosemion schouetedeni male / Aphyosemion calliurum female: Aphyosemion schoutedeni male / Aphyosemion labarrei female: Aphyosemion schoutedeni male / Epiplatys chaperi female: Epiplatys bifasciatus male / Epiplatys chaperi female: Epiplatys sexfasciatus male / Epiplatys chaperi female: Cynolebias bellotti male / Cynolebias whitei female: Cynolebias nigripinnis male / Cynolebias bellotti female: Cynolebias nigripinnis male / Cynolebias whitei female: I wonder why these eggs do not develop (or decompose). Possibly the only way to get out of this will be to have several females of these species spawning (controlled peat) without any males and see if such eggs might stay transparent for such a long time. These crossings behave just like the 3 crosses with Nothobranchius palmquisti female to males of "guntheri", "melanospilus" and "rachovi" in 1958. Also in these cases not a single egg (out of much larger numbers of eggs) did develop. After up to half a year these eggs decomposed in the yolk ball which fell into oil drops.

The crossing procedure is interesting from a breeder's point of view. Although the results certainly are rather poor, it is good sport because it might be difficult in at least some cases. Try to cross p.i. a Cynolebias nigripinnis male to a Nothobranchius guentheri female. This odd cross I made up my mind to try in the spring of 1958. After some initiate training (2 liters glass) on deep mud the partners were used of each other and from their behavior it was easy to see that both fish were willing to spawn each other. Male "nigripinnis" dived deep into the fine (screened) mud and only his brilliant caudal fin was seen waving over the mud. Female "guntheri" placed herself very close but did not try to dive, she was patiently waiting just over the surface of the mud. So things went on hours after hours. I took away most of the mud and apparently some sort of "normal" spawning then took place in clouds of mud. Many eggs were collected, but naturally all got fungus within a few days. It is interesting that the spawning instinct commonly is so strong in annual killies that even crossings (using isolated females and males) might start within a few minutes after the setting up of the breeding team. I had the most difficulties with the three species of Epiplatys and Aplocheilus lineatus. Normally these males need long training and "living together with" strange females, before normal courting takes place. The new "bifasciatus" seems to be the best male for crossings. Also the Epiplatys male wants much more lighting of the tank than do the Aphyosemion etc. This year's crossings in Aphyosemion took place in almost quite darkness. Most 1957/58 crossings were made in the normal 2-4 liter glasses standing on a shelf in a way that tanks were lighted from below (only lighting a small part of the bottom of the glass and one side). Possibly this strange lighting helps in breaking down the "aversion" of the male.

Total numbers of "crossings" (as some are made on mud, maybe eggs were liberated by the female without the aid of the male) are now 63. Of these 31 crosses (different combinations) gave the development of a distinct embryo in eggs. Of these crosses 21 different ones came to hatching, but not all hatched fry were livable. Until now 8 different hybrids came to maturity (maybe only 7, because I have got more and more doubt of the reliability of the Cynopoecilus ladigesi-melanotaenia cross which now is made one more and in both "directions". However I do not find any explanation where a fault might sit). As I now keep about 40 different species (or races) in killies, this means about 166 different combinations theoretically. You understand that it will not be finished in the near future indeed.

Small female "calabaricus" has beaten her "egg record" which she spawned in less than 24 hours a week ago. Today I cut out her 84 fertile eggs from a spawning of less than 24 hours. Might she reach the "100 eggs." She was born in autumn 1957 and she spawns together with one of her brothers of the same age. Old Aphyosemions normally are not good breeders. Before she dies, I hope that her offspring will swim happily in your tank.







Copyright 2022
Richard J. Sexton